Order OnlineCurrent Ice Cream and Italian Ice Flavors
Current Ice Cream and Italian Ice Flavors
Pete’s Sweet Treats publishes rotating flavor lists for its Sarasota shop. The ice cream, oat-milk-based, pint, and boozy lists below reproduce the shop’s publicly posted selections dated July 10, 2026. The Italian ice list is dated June 28, 2026. A listed flavor may sell out or change.
Ice cream flavors
- Vanilla
- Chocolate
- Coffee Oreo
- Lavender Honey
- Black Raspberry
- Mint Chip
- Peanut M&M
- Oreo Classic
- Chai Tea Spice and Brownie
- Huckleberry
- Corny Classic
Boozy ice cream
The official list marks this section for guests age 21 and older.
- Peanut Butter & Jelly
- Rum Raisin
Oat-milk-based selections
The official list uses a separate oat-milk-based category. Category labels do not confirm ingredient, allergen, or cross-contact suitability; call before ordering for dietary questions.
- Oreo Cookie
- Mint Chip
- Chocolate
Published pint flavors
- Eggnog
- Pistachio
- Chocolate
- Cookie Dough
- Coffee Oreo
- Chocolate Chip
- Black Raspberry Oreo
- Cinnamon Toast Crunch
- Tiramisu
- Chocolate Peanut Butter
- Lemon Poppy Seed
- Butter Pecan
- Salted Caramel Pecan
- Lavender Honey
- Banana Pudding
- Sarasota P.D.
- Birthday Cake
- Snickers
- Chai Tea Spice and Brownie
Italian ice flavors
- Lemon
- Mango
- Peach
- Strawberry
- Pineapple
- Piña Colada
- Watermelon
- Swedish Fish
- Root Beer
- Cotton Candy
- Cherry
- Blue Raspberry
How to confirm a flavor
Call 941-217-4859 or check the current online menu. For ingredient, allergen, and dietary questions, speak with the shop directly rather than relying on a flavor name.
Confirm today’s selection
Flavors rotate and a listed flavor may sell out or change. Check the current in-store board or live ordering menu, and call Pete when a particular flavor matters. Current prices are shown in the shop and on the ordering platform; delivery and pickup prices may differ.
Information checked July 12, 2026: Pete’s Sweet Treats’ official website and the linked online ordering menu. Flavors, hours, pricing, and availability can change; confirm current details before a special trip.